Wednesday, March 29, 2023
Excellent article by Mr. Wesley J. Smith - please see www.lifeandhope.com.
Blog
Podcast
Donate
Share
March 28, 2023
Terri Schiavo Case Was a Culture-of-Death Tipping Point
Wesley J. Smith
The March 31, 2005, court-ordered death of Terri Schiavo was an ominous cultural tipping point. As many readers will recall, the legal case began when Terri’s husband Michael Schiavo applied to remove the feeding tube from his profoundly cognitively disabled wife so that she would die by dehydration. When Terri’s parents Bob and Mary Schindler, joined by her siblings Bobby and Suzanne, fought the plan in court, profoundly important cultural and legal battle lines were drawn that were destined to change the country.
The legal battle raged for several years during which the country agonized and argued about the right and moral course. When her case began, few were aware that cognitively disabled patients could legally be made to die via the removal of feeding tubes. A few years later, after Terri’s family (in alliance with the disability rights and pro-life organizations) failed to save her life, this form of quasi-euthanasia was endorsed by polling majorities.
The public’s general acceptance of Terri’s dehydration followed a familiar pattern often seen as the culture-of-death slippery slope slip slides away. Initially, most people were shocked. But as the media pounded the drum in support of Michael, attitudes changed. This cultural shift was aided by prominent bioethicists and politicians assuring the public that taking away Terri’s feeding tube was not only legal—true—but ethically justified. By the time Terri was made to die agonizingly over two weeks—and despite Terri’s brother stating that she had become so desiccated blood was pooling in her eyes—most of the country became convinced that her forced death was both right and compassionate.
Looking back nearly 20 years later, Terri’s case can be judged as a cultural cudgel that crushed the sanctity of life. These days, society’s primary purpose is popularly understood to be the prevention and elimination of suffering—even if that means eliminating the sufferer. In this nihilistic climate, killing—when supposedly motivated by “compassion”—often finds strong public support.
This shift has led to radical changes in our laws. When Terri died, only Oregon had legalized assisted suicide. Today, nine jurisdictions have passed statutes allowing doctors to prescribe lethal drugs to dying patients (Oregon, Hawaii, Colorado, New Mexico, Maine, New Jersey, Vermont, California, plus the District of Columbia). These states encompass about one-third of the U.S. population.
Not only that, but most of these states have already begun the slippery slope process of expanding access to assisted suicide from that originally permitted, such as shortened waiting periods, allowing doctors to examine assisted suicide requesters over the Internet rather than in person, and allowing nurse practitioners to lethally prescribe. Vermont has done away with its residency requirements—likely followed soon by Oregon—opening the door to “suicide tourism” and potentially allowing patients throughout the nation to receive lethal doses who never meet the prescribing doctor in the flesh, or even enter the state.
Meanwhile, the euthanasia movement is striving to increase the number of jurisdictions that permit doctors to assist suicides. This year, there will be fraught political battles over assisted suicide legalization in New York, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Minnesota, and Maryland, just to name a few.
Not content to await such changes, euthanasia advocacy groups promote suicide by self-starvation/dehydration to the elderly and people with disabilities, known in movement parlance as VSED (“voluntary stopping eating and drinking”). VSED is a form of quasi-assisted suicide. Starving oneself is an agonizing way to die—as it clearly was for Terri Schiavo if she was in any way conscious—so a doctor is usually required to palliate the agony. Otherwise, most people can’t complete the process.
Activists also promote “VSED by advance directive” for patients who willingly eat and drink. The idea is to allow people to create written legally binding documents ordering themselves starved to death should they become incompetent. Under these proposals, caregivers would be required to refuse sustenance to their patients—even if the patient asked for food and water—under the theory that the decision by the formerly competent patient should apply whether the person still wants to starve or not.
How bad could this death agenda get? Canada—our closest cultural cousin—provides an alarming illustration. Our northern neighbor not only allows lethal injection euthanasia, but patients need not be terminally ill to qualify. Thus, lonely, frail elderly patients have been killed by doctors, as well as people with disabilities and chronic diseases—even the depressed. Next year the mentally ill are scheduled to be qualified legally for euthanasia, and the move is also afoot to allow children to be killed—perhaps without their parents’ knowledge or permission if doctors deem the child to be sufficiently “mature.” Not only that, but in Ontario, someone who has been accepted for euthanasia will be contacted by an organ transplant charity and asked for their liver, heart, pancreas, and kidneys.
If the same awful death paradigm develops here, the Terri Schiavo debacle will have paved the way. In the years since society nodded at the dehydration death of a helpless woman, we can trace a profound lessening in our commitment to the value of human life, along with a concomitant increase in poisonous utilitarianism in health care. Indeed, the day may soon come when killing seriously ill, elderly, and severely disabled patients is not merely seen as a legitimate “end-of-life choice,” but also a normalized way of death.
Tags
assisted suicide
Bobby Schindler
euthanasia
medical assistance in dying
Terri Schiavo
Blog
Podcast
Donate
Newsletter
Categories
Abortion
Animal Welfare
Bioethics
Conscience
COVID-19
Euthanasia
Genetic Manipulation
Health Care
Human Dignity
Human Exceptionalism
Human Flourishing
Human Rights
Human Trafficking
Nature and Conservation
Patient Care
Stem Cell Research
Suicide by Physician
Transgenderism
Transhumanism
Uncategorized
Previous Post
Belgium to Allow Repeated Gender Changes
Blog Podcast Donate Newsletter About
Center on Human Exceptionalism
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2023
(9230)
-
▼
March
(321)
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Love always hopes. Love always perseveres.
- Love is patient. Love is kind.
- Thank you ABBA! Thank you JESUS!
- JESUS is LORD!
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Dear, dear U.S. Congressman Josh Gottheimer - plea...
- Please help give land back to Native Americans and...
- Please help end the Mafia ad other organized crime...
- Please help end slavery throughout the world today!
- Please help end child pornography in less than six...
- Dear, dear President Joe Biden - please help end t...
- Abortion is not health care.
- Please help end anti-Semitism and racism.
- Please help improve the justice System. Do the po...
- Please help rep-eal, or change all the problems wi...
- Please help end the destruction of life.
- Love one another.
- Looking for a church to attend.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Love always protects. Love always trusts.
- Dear, dear President Joe Biden - please help end t...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Abortion is not health care.
- Please help end the flow of taxpayers' dollars to ...
- Please help improve the Health Care System today -...
- Please help end anti-Semitism and racism today!
- Please help repeal, or change all the problems wit...
- Please help end the destruction of life.
- If at all possible, live at peace with one another.
- Looking for a church to attend.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Please help improve te Health Care System - please...
- Excellent article by Mr. Wesley J. Smith - please ...
- A wonderful article by Wesley J. Smith - please he...
- Please help repeal, or change all the problems wit...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Please help end the destruction of life.
- Love always protects. Love always trusts.
- We love, because HE first loved us.
- Love one another.
- Looking for a church to attend.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Please don't forget to pray for the abortionists, ...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Please don't forget to ask for wisdom.
- Please don't forget to pray for our leaders and th...
- JESUS is the Light of the world.
- JESUS is the Word of GOD.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Looking for a church to attend.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Flee sexual immorality.
- Abhor evil, cling to what is good.
- For the love of money is the root of all kinds of ...
- You cannot love both GOD and money.
- We are to be as shrewd as snakes and as innocent a...
- Love is not proud. Love is not easily angered.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Love does no harm to his neighbor, therefore, love...
- Love never fails.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Thank you ABBA for the love, joy, peace, mercy, gr...
- Thank you ABBA! Thank you JESUS!
- JESUS is LORD!
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Please improve the justice System. Do the poor an...
- Please help improve the Health Care System - pleas...
- Looking for a church to attend.
- Then Jesus turned, and saw them following, and sai...
- Love is patient. Love is kind.
- Love always hopes. Love always perseveres.
- Love always protects. Love always trusts.
- Dear, dear U.S. Senator Cory Booker - please help ...
- Dear, dear U.S. Senator Robert Menendez - please h...
- Dear, dear U.S. Congressman Josh Gottheimer - plea...
- Dear, dear Vice President Kamala Harris - abortion...
- Dear, dear President Joe Biden - please support th...
- Please help give land back to Native Americans and...
- Please help end pornography and erotica.
- Please help end the Mafia and other organized crim...
- Please help end slavery throughout the world today!
- Please help end anti-Semitism and racism today!
- Abortion is not health care.
- Please help end the flow of taxpayers' dollars to ...
- Please help end child pornography in less than six...
- Please help repeal, or change all the problems wit...
- Please help end the destruction of life.
- Love one another.
- Looking for a church to attend.
- JESUS is the Living Water!
-
▼
March
(321)
No comments:
Post a Comment